Collectability of Damages
McHenry Savings Bank (“MSB”) sued attorney Michael Cortina and his law firm, SmithAmundsen (“Defendants”), for legal malpractice arising from their representation of MSB in an unsuccessful foreclosure action. The trial court granted Defendants’ motion to strike and dismiss. The Appellate Court of Illinois, Second District, affirmed. With respect to alleged pretrial errors, it explained that “a trial was held in the foreclosure case” and so “it cannot be said that, but for Cortina’s alleged negligent pretrial conduct, MSB lost its case and suffered damages.” Id. at ¶ 36. As for any errors during the trial, the Appellate Court held that the Foreclosure Court’s basis for granting judgment against MSG was “legally unsound,” meaning “Cortina cannot be held accountable.” Id. at ¶ 42. Even if causation could have been shown, the Appellate Court explained that no damage resulted since MSB would be “seeking damages from defendants that it was never entitled to due to mortgagors’ discharge in bankruptcy.” Id. at ¶ 51.
(This is for informational purposes and is not legal advice.)